A while back Ruthie
started a series about parenting choices and the subject she led off with was circumcision. I made a promise to respond, explaining why we chose not to circumcise our son, but I got busy with moving. So I've decided to go ahead and post it here.
If you've ever perused the left side bar of my blog you may have seen the link titled
The Truth about Circumcision. Phoebe Gleeson of NOCIRC of Oklahoma has put together an excellent "Chat about Circumcision" which explains my reason for not circumcising. I have no desire to reinvent the wheel here so please go over and read her
short comprehensive article on the subject. If you read nothing else on the subject, read this. It is full of informative links for those who wish to know more.
Growing up, I had always assumed that circumcision was just what you did. I didn't question it. When I was pregnant with my first child I checked out just about every baby book from the Boston Public Library. I came to the conclusion from the short snipits in the books that seemed the most reasonable to me that circumcision simply was unnecessary. I learned that non-religious circumcision in this country was started as a way to stop masturbation. Well, I thought that was ridiculous and I knew that it sure as hell didn't work. But I still didn't think that circumcision was all that bad, so I told my husband that my research said it was not necessary, but if he wanted to do it I would go along as long as the baby was given pain meds. I later found out that pain meds usually aren't given and when they are they don't work very well because the good strong stuff is dangerous for newborns. But we didn't know that then. My husband decided that it would be wrong to put the baby through even a medicated circumcision if it wasn't necessary. (Have I mentioned that I love my husband? I do.) It turned out to be a moot point when we found out we were having a girl.
After she was born, I learned a lot more about circumcision. Do you want to know what I learned? Go
read that article I told you about. It's much more informative than anything I'm going to tell you here. I don't mind if you stop reading this. Go ahead.
Ok, you're back. Great. The more that I learned about circumcision the more horrified I was that my husband and brother and almost every man my age that I knew had been through this. Circumcision rates in the U.S. were around their peak when we were born and have been steadily declining since then. I was surprised to learn that in some areas of the country circumcision rates have dropped to 30 percent. That means more than two thirds of boys in places like California are being left intact (not circumcised). I'll be sending my daughters to college on the West Coast or Europe (where they rarely circumcise). Why? Now this is the kicker. I'm honestly embarrassed to admit this, but this little piece of information was the thing that turned me from riding the fence on this subject to being strongly anti-circumcision. Women who have been with both intact and circumcised men report that they are twice as likely to orgasm with an intact man and they prefer sex with an intact man nine to one. Of course we all know that circumcised men can be great in bed, but why do something that might hinder that for my son and future daughter-in-law? She had better appreciate what I've done (or not done) for her and wait on me hand and foot in my old age. Ha, ha. [By the way, I'll be happy to cite a source for this info as soon as I get back on my own computer with internet that's not stolen from the neighbors who were good enough to leave theirs unsecured. A blessing be upon their house.]
When I was pregnant with my second daughter I was fully convinced, so when my midwife asked if we would circumcise a boy I said no. She said, "Thank God." I had met my first real life anti-circumcision advocate. I've met others since then.
So my son is not circumcised. We have not had any problems, and I feel confidant that if we did that we could solve them the same way that we would if our uncircumcised daughters had problems. Many times as I've changed his diapers in the last seven months I've felt thankful that I found out soon enough to save my son from being hurt. I know several parents who found out too late and deeply regret what can't be undone. I know a few men who wish that they could undo what was done without their permission. And I know one mom whose child was circumcised without her consent. But thankfully I have a number of friends who have chosen not to circumcise (including the girls' fabulous godparents) and who have also had no problems.
So there it is. Foreskins are not some kind of scary things that we must do away with. They are normal body parts with a purpose and my son is keeping his.
[Click on the circumcision link in the labels below if you want to read my rant about the circumcision and AIDS propaganda.]
Labels: circumcision, parenting